Great read what you’re saying is essentially that human in the loop is not gonna work because human nature makes it impossible to not let the AI make the decision decisions for you, which I think in many ways is true. But another aspect of human in the loop is essentially changing the routines to make it a necessary step to sign off as a human being in a creative process. Human presence is about to become prime real estate in user experience design.
Thanks! One correction though: not impossible - the undesigned loop decays, the designed one can hold. That's why the Navy example is there: human out of the loop, by design. Decay is a design problem, not a verdict.
Your second point is interesting, and you're probably right that it's about to become prime real estate. What worries me: once presence sells, companies will make the human visible - and it will change nothing. A safeguard assumed, not built. In other words, the premium alibi.
Great read what you’re saying is essentially that human in the loop is not gonna work because human nature makes it impossible to not let the AI make the decision decisions for you, which I think in many ways is true. But another aspect of human in the loop is essentially changing the routines to make it a necessary step to sign off as a human being in a creative process. Human presence is about to become prime real estate in user experience design.
Thanks! One correction though: not impossible - the undesigned loop decays, the designed one can hold. That's why the Navy example is there: human out of the loop, by design. Decay is a design problem, not a verdict.
Your second point is interesting, and you're probably right that it's about to become prime real estate. What worries me: once presence sells, companies will make the human visible - and it will change nothing. A safeguard assumed, not built. In other words, the premium alibi.